Your index fund can finish the year up while some of the stocks inside it finish down. If you own the fund, you can't harvest the losses of those stocks that are down. You can only sell the fund. Today I'm covering direct indexing, which is built to reach those losses by taking off the index fund wrapper and buying the shares directly. And I'll show you how it works.
My name is Nathan Donohue, and I've spent over 15 years working with recipients of stock compensation.
Direct indexing means you own the individual stocks of an index in your own account instead of one fund that holds them for you.
Now let's look at a hypothetical situation. You put $500,000 into an index fund, it's a good year, and the account ends up 10%. We're now at $550,000. You own one position, the index fund, and it's up, so there are no losses to harvest.
If, however, you own the individual stocks directly and you have that same good year, a handful of those companies in the index can finish down. And let's assume together those stocks down are worth $15,000 less than you paid.
That loss can offset $15,000 of gain somewhere else, like company stock you've held for years and are looking to sell. If your losses are bigger than your gains, up to $3,000 a year can offset ordinary income, and the rest carries forward to future tax years.
The second advantage of direct indexing is control. If you work at a company in the S&P 500, an S&P 500 fund owns your employer too. Now with customizable direct indexing, you can leave it out. So your index stops adding to the position you're already trying to shrink.
So that's the case for it. The case against starts with cost. Direct indexing generally costs more than a low-cost index fund. Also, swapping stocks in and out means your return can drift from the index in either direction, which is called tracking error.
Harvesting losses also just defers the tax rather than erases it altogether. The replacement stock starts with a lower cost basis, which can mean a bigger gain when you sell later.
Then there's the wash sale rule. Acquire the same stock within 30 days before or after selling it at a loss, and the loss can be disallowed. An RSU vest can count, which is one more reason to keep your employer out of the direct index.
And the losses can dry up. If the market climbs for several years, fewer of your stocks sit below what you paid. So there can be less to harvest unless new money goes in.
Before moving forward, I'd want three questions answered. Which gains are you offsetting, and over how many years? What does it cost, all in, next to an index fund? And how do you ultimately get out? The answers could point to direct indexing, or they might point back to a low-cost index fund.
If you're weighing this against a concentrated stock position, click the link in the description and tell us a little about your situation. If we can work with you in your state, we'll set up a time to talk. A conversation now can cost a lot less than unwinding a strategy that never fit in the first place.
Now, this video is educational and general in nature. It is not tax, legal, or investment advice, and it is not a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security. The figures used here are hypothetical, for illustration only, and reflect federal rules as of 2026, which can change. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. State taxes and your individual circumstances can meaningfully change the outcome.