Today we're looking at a hypothetical situation for a married couple who want to retire. They're both 55, and they're ready to leave their jobs. They have $3 million saved, but $2 million of it is in their employer's stock. Can they retire?
The stock is all vested shares. The rest of the portfolio is about $700,000 in a diversified traditional 401(k) and $300,000 in cash. There's no debt. And we're leaving their home and unvested grants out of this scenario.
They expect to withdraw $120,000 a year, and that includes their estimated taxes and health insurance. For this example, we'll assume they have no pension or other income in retirement.
Now, based on those figures, that's a 4% distribution rate on the $3 million portfolio, which can be a decent starting point.
But that starting percentage doesn't tell us whether the money can support 30 or 40 years of retirement.
My name is Nathan Donohue, and I've spent over 15 years working with recipients of stock compensation. There are 3 questions I'd want this couple to answer before they give their retirement notice.
Question 1 is what happens if the stock falls.
Two-thirds of this couple's investments depend on one company. And once they retire, there are no paychecks coming in to refill their savings.
Let's suppose, purely as a stress test, the company's stock falls 40% right after they retire. We'll hold the other accounts unchanged to isolate that one risk. This isn't a prediction, and in a real downturn those other accounts could fall too.
In this example, their $2 million stock position could fall to about $1.2 million. Their total investments could be roughly $2.2 million, down from $3 million, before withdrawals or taxes.
That same $120,000 burn rate is now about 5.5% of that smaller balance.
And they could still be fine. But selling while the stock is down takes more shares to cover the same bills. And if the price recovers later, the shares they sold miss out.
In this example, I'd want to know what spending they could reduce, and which account would cover next year's bills if the stock stayed down.
That account choice also changes what they owe in taxes, which is question number 2. How much is available after taxes?
That $2 million of stock is a market value. If they sell, some of it could go to taxes.
Let's assume these vested shares sit in a taxable brokerage account, with an adjusted cost basis of $1 million. Selling the entire position for $2 million would produce about a $1 million capital gain.
The tax on that gain is a separate number. It depends on how long you've held the shares, their other income sources, and federal and state rules.
A traditional 401(k) withdrawal generally adds taxable income as well. And at 55, they'd need to check their plan's access rules, and whether any exception to the early-withdrawal tax applies.
So I'd compare which shares could fund their spending, what gain each sale would realize, and how that fits with the rest of their income.
Question number 3 is what changes when the paycheck stops.
I'd check their $120,000 estimate against the life they're planning. Does it include travel, home repairs, and replacing a car every few years?
Have they priced in health coverage after leaving their employer? At 55, they could be paying premiums for about 10 years before Medicare eligibility, which generally starts at 65.
They also need to check what happens to their unvested grants when they leave, under their own grant agreements.
Their $300,000 in cash could cover about 2 and a half years of those withdrawals, ignoring interest and inflation. And that does give them some time. Whether the rest of the portfolio can fund the decades after that is still an open question.
For this couple, I'd leave the retirement date open until they've priced the tax cost, confirmed access to their accounts, and tested their spending through a long downturn and rising costs.
So, our question: can they retire? They may have enough. And those 3 questions are how we'd start to find out.
If company stock is a big part of your retirement plan, click the link in the description and tell us a little about your situation. If we can work with you in your state, we'll set up a time to talk.
Now, this video is educational and general in nature. It is not tax, legal, or investment advice, and it is not a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security. The figures used here are hypothetical, for illustration only, and reflect federal rules as of 2026, which can change. State taxes and your individual circumstances can meaningfully change the outcome.