Executive Summary

  • Net unrealized appreciation (NUA) is the growth in employer stock inside your 401(k), above what the plan paid for the shares (its cost basis).
  • Take the shares out as shares in a lump-sum distribution and the cost basis is taxed as ordinary income that year. The NUA is taxed as long-term capital gain when you sell.
  • Roll employer shares into an IRA and NUA treatment is gone. Traditional IRA withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income.
  • NUA tends to work best with a low cost basis and a high ordinary tax rate. It can be a poor fit if the basis is high, you'd owe the 10% early-withdrawal tax on the basis, or you'd stay concentrated just for the tax treatment.
  • The whole plan balance generally has to come out within one tax year, after a triggering event such as leaving your job or reaching age 59½.

How NUA works

If your 401(k) offers a company stock fund, you may have years of paychecks sitting in it. Every contribution bought shares at that day's price. If the stock has climbed since, the shares can be worth several times what the plan paid. That growth is your net unrealized appreciation.

This article focuses on employer shares held in the pre-tax portion of a qualified retirement plan and the usual lump-sum distribution strategy. After-tax employee contributions can have different rules.

Most of a pre-tax 401(k) follows one simple rule. Every dollar that comes out, whether from the plan or later from an IRA, is taxed as ordinary income. Employer stock gets an exception. If the shares come out of the plan as shares (an in-kind distribution) as part of a lump-sum distribution, Section 402(e)(4) of the tax code lets the growth above the plan's cost basis skip tax when you receive it.

RSU and ESPP shares in your brokerage account don't count. NUA applies only to employer stock that comes out of a qualified retirement plan like a 401(k).

Here's what happens to each piece, as IRS Publication 575 lays it out:

  • The cost basis (what the plan paid for the shares) is taxed as ordinary income in the year of the distribution.
  • The NUA isn't taxed until you sell. Then it's long-term capital gain, even if you sell the next day!
  • Growth after the distribution is a capital gain, too, short-term or long-term depending on how long you hold the shares after the distribution.

There's one more perk. Under Treasury regulations, the NUA portion of your gain isn't subject to the 3.8% net investment income tax, even if you sell years later. Growth after the distribution can be, and both the NUA and the cost basis still count toward the income threshold for that tax.

Say your 401(k) holds $600,000 of company stock, and the plan's cost basis in those shares is $120,000, so the NUA is $480,000. Take the shares out in kind and $120,000 is ordinary income that year. Sell later and the $480,000 is long-term capital gain. Assume a flat 35% ordinary rate and the 20% top long-term rate, and federal tax could be roughly $138,000. That's $42,000 up front and $96,000 when you sell. Roll the same shares into an IRA and withdraw them at 35%, and it could be roughly $210,000, paid over time. That's a gap of about $72,000 from one decision. The illustration leaves out investment returns, state tax and the value of deferring tax inside the IRA, and those can narrow the gap or reverse it.

RuleShares taken out in kind (NUA)Shares rolled to an IRA
Tax when the shares leave the planOrdinary income on the cost basisNone
Tax on the NUALong-term capital gain when soldOrdinary income when withdrawn
Growth after the moveCapital gain, by holding periodOrdinary income when withdrawn
3.8% net investment income taxNot on the NUA. Can apply to later growthNot on withdrawals
DividendsTaxable each yearTax-deferred in the IRA
10% early-withdrawal taxCan apply to the cost basisCan apply to withdrawals
Required minimum distributionsNone on these sharesApply to the IRA
At deathNo basis step-up on the NUAWithdrawals taxed as ordinary income

Federal rules for employer stock in a 401(k) or other qualified plan, 2026.

The rules for a lump-sum distribution

NUA works like a coupon with an expiration date. It's gone the moment your company stock lands in an IRA, as the IRS's model rollover notice spells out. Before that, the fine print is in Section 402(e)(4), and it has four parts.

  1. A triggering event. For an employee, the payout has to come after you reach age 59½, or because you left your job (separation from service) or died. Disability counts only for the self-employed.
  2. The whole balance, in one tax year. Everything to your credit in the plan has to be paid out within a single tax year. A payout split across two tax years generally doesn't qualify. The rest of the account can generally be rolled into an IRA in the same year, while the company shares go to a taxable brokerage account as shares.
  3. Every plan of the same type. The tax code treats all of an employer's plans of the same type (pension, profit-sharing or stock bonus) as one plan. If your employer has more than one plan of the same type, they all have to be emptied in that same tax year.
  4. Shares, not cash. The shares you use for NUA must be distributed in kind. Selling them and distributing the cash proceeds does not qualify.

Your plan also has to be able to pay out shares. The plan administrator reports the NUA on your Form 1099-R for the year of the distribution.

When NUA can work well

No single number decides it, but a few factors tend to tip the math toward NUA.

  • A low cost basis. The smaller the basis compared with the shares' value, the less ordinary income you take up front, and the more of the value can get long-term capital gains rates. Shares bought many years ago at much lower prices are the classic case.
  • A high ordinary tax rate later. In 2026, ordinary income tax rates top out at 37%, and long-term capital gains rates top out at 20%. If your IRA withdrawals would be taxed in a high bracket, NUA can move the growth on your company stock from the higher rate to the lower one.
  • A plan to diversify. NUA doesn't require you to keep the stock. You can sell the shares soon after the distribution and still get long-term capital gains rates on the NUA, which pairs well with reducing a large position in one company.
  • Smaller required minimum distributions. Shares in a taxable account aren't subject to required minimum distributions, so keeping them out of an IRA leaves a smaller balance for those required withdrawals.

When NUA may not be worth it

NUA has costs, and they can outweigh the rate difference.

  • A high cost basis. Flip the hypothetical. If the same $600,000 of stock had a $480,000 basis, you'd pay ordinary income tax on $480,000 this year to get the lower rate on just $120,000. Rolling the shares into an IRA and deferring the tax could come out ahead.
  • A large tax bill now. The tax on the cost basis is due for the year of the distribution, even if you don't sell a share. A payout of shares alone may have little or no federal tax withheld, so that tax can come due with your estimated payments or your return. A large basis can also push the rest of that year's income into a higher bracket.
  • The 10% early-withdrawal tax. If you're under 59½, the 10% additional tax can apply to the cost basis, though not to the NUA, unless an exception applies. One exception covers payouts after you leave your employer in or after the year you turn 55.
  • Lower rates ahead, or a long horizon. If you expect a low tax bracket in retirement, or have many years of tax-deferred growth ahead, the IRA's deferral may be worth more than the rate difference. Dividends on shares in a taxable account are taxed every year, too.
  • Holding one stock for the tax break. If the stock falls after the distribution, the loss can erase more than the tax you saved. NUA works the same way if you sell soon after, so the tax treatment alone isn't a reason to keep a concentrated position. Our video on holding too much company stock walks through how those exposures add up.
  • Heirs. If you still hold the shares at death, the NUA doesn't get a step-up in basis. Growth after the distribution does get the step-up, so your heirs' basis is the value at death minus the NUA. Your heirs owe long-term capital gains tax on the NUA when they sell.

Five checks before you roll over

The rollover paperwork is the point of no return, so these come first.

  1. Find the cost basis. Ask your plan administrator for the cost basis of your company shares and the NUA, not just their current value.
  2. Confirm the plan pays out shares. Ask whether the plan can distribute company stock as shares to a brokerage account, and whether you can roll the rest of the account to an IRA in the same year.
  3. Map the tax year. Plan the whole payout, including any other plans of the same type with the same employer, within one tax year. If you've already taken money out of the plan since leaving your job or turning 59½, ask a tax professional whether NUA is still available.
  4. Plan for the tax bill. Estimate the ordinary income tax on the cost basis and where the cash will come from. Our guide to safe harbor estimated taxes explains how to avoid an underpayment penalty when income isn't withheld.
  5. Run the numbers both ways. Compare NUA with a full IRA rollover, including state tax, how long you'd hold the shares and what you'd do with the proceeds.

Start with check 1. One call to your plan administrator gets you the cost basis, and that number shapes everything else on this list.

Related video: Before You Retire With Company Stock, Check These 3 Things

Running NUA against a full rollover is part of our equity compensation planning.

This is general education, not a recommendation. Whether NUA makes sense depends on your cost basis, your tax brackets now and later, state taxes, your cash needs, your other holdings and your goals. The dollar figures in this article are hypothetical illustrations, not projections or results, and they leave out investment returns, state taxes and the value of tax deferral. Plan rules and tax law can change, so confirm the details with your plan administrator and a tax professional before taking a distribution.

Have a question for a CFP® Professional?

Schedule a complimentary 60-minute intro. Our pricing is a flat annual fee - this fee calculator shows how that compares with an AUM% fee.

Book an intro call

Disclosures: The information provided is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice and should not be relied on as such. It is not a solicitation to buy or an offer to sell any security. It does not take into account any individual's particular investment objectives, financial situation, or needs. You should consult your own financial advisor, tax advisor, or attorney before acting on any information herein. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Figures and tax limits referenced are for the applicable tax year and are subject to change. Valence Wealth, LLC is a registered investment advisor in the State of Arizona. Registration does not imply any specific level of skill or training. References to employer stock describe how the tax rules work and are not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security. Hypothetical examples are not actual results or forecasts.

Sources